The Truth Behind Thanksgiving: An Open Response to Rachel Ruto's Glorification of Massacre, Injustice, and Colonialism

Her Excellency Mrs Rachel Ruto,

First Lady, Republic of Kenya,

State House,

Nairobi

Dear Mrs Ruto,

The real history of Thanksgiving is darker than you think.

In response to your recent praising of the American holiday, this epistle delves into its complex history, impact on Native American communities, and the importance of Truthsgiving. I hope it can clear your lopsided perspective of history.

In a recent statement, you were quoted in the media praising Thanksgiving and praying for Kenya to have a similar experience, seemingly unaware of its complex history and impact on Native American communities. It is crucial to shed light on the darker truths of this holiday, often overlooked in mainstream narratives.

The Myth vs. Reality of Thanksgiving

Contrary to popular belief, Thanksgiving's origins are steeped in colonialism and the subjugation of Native Americans. The widely held narrative of Pilgrims and Native Americans coming together in harmony is a distortion of history. The truth reveals a tale of exploitation and violence.

The so-called "first Thanksgiving" in 1621 did occur between Pilgrims and the Wampanoag tribe, but it wasn't the idyllic gathering portrayed in textbooks. The Wampanoag were not invited; instead, they arrived in response to gunfire, which they interpreted as a threat. Moreover, the Pilgrims' initial interaction with the Wampanoag involved theft of their winter provisions.

The Legacy of Colonisation

Thanksgiving's aftermath was far from peaceful. It marked the beginning of a tragic chapter in Native American history, characterised by land seizures, intentional contagion, and violence. European settlers repaid Native American hospitality with brutality, including massacres and forced displacement.

Subsequent "Thanksgiving" celebrations often commemorated triumphs over Native peoples, further perpetuating their marginalisation and suffering. The erasure of this history has perpetuated misconceptions and silenced Indigenous voices.

Why Truthsgiving Matters

Your praise of Thanksgiving underscores the need for Truthsgiving—a growing movement in America aimed at acknowledging the realities of colonialism and its ongoing impact. By understanding the true history of Thanksgiving, we can confront the systemic injustices faced by Native American communities.

Native American history is American history, and its omission from historical discourse perpetuates ignorance and perpetuates harm. Recognising and amplifying Native voices is essential for fostering understanding and addressing the root causes of historical and contemporary injustices.

Moving Forward with Gratitude and Accountability

As Americans celebrate Thanksgiving, it is important that they do so with a deeper understanding of its complexities. It is high time to honour Native resilience and resistance in the face of centuries of oppression. And also to commit to Truthsgiving—not just on the holiday, but every day—in a pivot to justice, equity, and reconciliation.

Your observations about Thanksgiving remind us of the importance of engaging critically with history and its implications. By embracing Truthsgiving, people can pave the way for a more inclusive and compassionate future.

Thanksgiving is more than just a day of feasting (or "a great harvest" as you seem to think it commemorates); it's a reminder of the unresolved wounds of colonialism and the resilience of Indigenous peoples. Your oversight underscores the urgency of truth-telling and reconciliation. Let us acknowledge Thanksgiving's complexities and commit to honouring Native American experiences and perspectives. Let us also recommit to justice and solidarity with Indigenous communities.